Netflix is home to countless popular shows and blockbuster hits, but many underrated Netflix shows deserve more recognition. These hidden gems offer unique storylines, strong character development, and creative storytelling that sometimes get overshadowed by heavily marketed titles.
Exploring these series not only expands your watchlist but also allows you to experience innovative ideas that mainstream hits often avoid. Whether you are a fan of drama, sci-fi, thriller, or comedy, there is something for everyone among these overlooked series.
By watching these underrated shows, viewers can find stories that are thought-provoking, emotionally engaging, and intellectually stimulating. Many of these shows have a loyal fan base, but they didn’t receive widespread attention, which is why they remain hidden treasures in Netflix’s vast catalogue.
Mindhunter: Deep Dive into Criminal Psychology
Mindhunter is one of the most intense and methodical crime dramas available on Netflix. It explores the early days of the FBI’s Behavioral Science Unit, focusing on profiling serial killers. Unlike many crime shows, it doesn’t rely on action or constant suspense but instead builds tension through deep psychological insights and carefully written dialogue.
The series emphasizes character development and realism. Agents Holden Ford and Bill Tench interview real-life serial killers to understand their motives, making the audience confront the darkness of human nature. Director David Fincher ensures that each scene captures a sense of psychological unease, while the actors deliver subtle but powerful performances.
Russian Doll: Comedy with Depth and Underrated Netflix Shows
Freepik
Russian Doll is a dark comedy with a unique time-loop twist. The protagonist, Nadia, repeatedly dies and resets her birthday party, forcing her to confront her life, past traumas, and relationships.
The show brilliantly balances humor with emotional depth, making it stand out among other comedy-dramas. Every reset challenges Nadia to understand herself and grow, creating a captivating and introspective viewing experience.
Key Feature:
- Dark humor paired with meaningful life lessons
- Fast-paced storytelling with an emotional core
- Excellent performance by the lead actress
- Clever exploration of existential questions through comedy
Russian Doll is a perfect example of a show that may be underrated simply because it defies genre expectations, blending comedy, drama, and existential storytelling seamlessly.
The OA: Mystery and Underrated Netflix Shows
The OA is one of Netflix’s most ambitious and mysterious series. It follows Prairie, a young woman who disappeared for seven years and returns with her sight restored, now calling herself “The OA.” The show blends mystery, thriller, and supernatural elements, taking viewers on a journey through near-death experiences, metaphysical questions, and emotional exploration. Its unconventional narrative challenges traditional storytelling and rewards viewers who engage deeply with the series.
1. Unique Narrative Structure
The OA uses a nonlinear storytelling approach, shifting between past, present, and alternate dimensions. This structure keeps viewers intrigued and allows the story to unfold gradually, revealing character motivations and hidden connections. The unpredictable narrative style encourages critical thinking and attentive viewing.
2. Complex Characters
The series features layered characters whose motives and development are revealed over time. Prairie, in particular, is a deeply complex protagonist struggling with trauma, identity, and purpose. Supporting characters each bring unique perspectives, enhancing the depth and richness of the story.
3. Supernatural and Sci-Fi Elements
The show masterfully blends supernatural phenomena with science fiction concepts. From near-death experiences to interdimensional travel, these elements create a sense of wonder while exploring existential questions. The integration of sci-fi and metaphysics makes the narrative compelling and thought-provoking.
4. Emotional and Philosophical Themes
The OA is not just a mystery or sci-fi show; it is a philosophical exploration of life, death, and human connection. Themes of trauma, redemption, resilience, and the search for meaning are central, giving the series emotional depth that resonates long after viewing.
5. Why It’s Underrated
Despite its creativity and devoted fanbase, The OA remains underrated due to its complex narrative and genre-defying approach. Many viewers may find it challenging, but those who persist are rewarded with a richly layered story that is both intellectually stimulating and emotionally satisfying.
Dark: Complex Time Travel Made Engaging
Freepik
Dark is a German-language thriller that explores time travel and its impact on several interconnected families. Its plot is intricate, with multiple timelines and generations, demanding attention and active engagement from the viewer.
Key Feature:
- Intricate web of characters and timelines
- Explores themes of fate, free will, and consequences
- Stunning cinematography with a haunting musical score
- Keeps audiences guessing until the very end
The complexity of Dark may intimidate casual viewers, but its storytelling brilliance, intellectual depth, and emotional resonance make it one of the most rewarding hidden Netflix gems.
Maniac: Surreal Experimentation and Underrated Netflix Shows
Maniac stars Emma Stone and Jonah Hill in a mind-bending series that mixes psychological exploration, surrealism, and dark comedy. The story follows two strangers who participate in a mysterious pharmaceutical trial, leading them through bizarre alternate realities and fragmented memories.
Each episode introduces a new imaginative world, keeping the narrative fresh and unpredictable while exploring human psychology. The show’s unconventional style challenges viewers to reflect on the nature of reality and personal transformation.
Despite its complex storytelling, the emotional core remains strong, focusing on loneliness, connection, and healing. The lead actors deliver exceptional performances that ground the surreal visuals in relatable human emotion.
I Am Not Okay With This: Teenage Angst and Superpowers
I Am Not Okay With This follows Sydney, a teenage girl dealing with grief, bullying, and her newly discovered telekinetic powers. The series captures the emotional intensity of adolescence while blending in supernatural elements, making her journey both relatable and intriguing.
The writing balances humor and drama, showing Sydney’s struggles in a way that feels genuine and heartfelt. Viewers quickly connect with her as she navigates friendships, family, and her own identity.
The show’s dialogue is witty and sharp, adding levity to otherwise show’s dialogue is witty and sharp, adding levity to otherwise intense moments. Its short, focused seasons make it perfect for binge-watching without filler episodes, much like how trending home workouts can deliver quick, effective results without unnecessary complexity.
The End of the F***ing World: Underrated Netflix Shows
The End of the F**ing World* follows James and Alyssa, two troubled teenagers on a road trip full of misadventures. The series blends dark humor with real emotional stakes, making it a deeply human story.
The show begins with a quirky, almost absurd tone but gradually reveals the emotional depth and vulnerabilities of the main characters. The narrative evolves in three stages: introduction, conflict, and resolution, each layered with psychological insight.
Key Feature: Underrated Netflix Shows
- Sharp, realistic dialogue that feels authentic
- Dark humor combined with emotional storytelling
- Concise seasons with tightly crafted arcs
- Explores themes of morality, identity, and connection
It may not have achieved mainstream success, but its combination of humor, darkness, and heart makes it a hidden gem worth discovering.
Why These Underrated Netflix Shows Are Worth Watching
Freepik
These series show that popularity doesn’t always equal quality. Many underrated Netflix shows take creative risks, exploring genres and themes that mainstream hits often avoid. They challenge viewers intellectually, emotionally, and visually, offering a richer viewing experience.
They encourage exploring beyond heavily marketed titles, showcase experimental storytelling, and introduce fresh perspectives. Many also cultivate loyal fan communities who discuss and analyze the content passionately. By watching these hidden gems, viewers can enjoy a deeper, more meaningful Netflix journey.
Conclusion: Underrated Netflix Shows
While many viewers chase mainstream hits, there is a treasure trove of underrated Netflix shows waiting to be discovered. From the psychological depth of Mindhunter to the existential humor of Russian Doll and the emotional intensity of The End of the F**ing World*, these series offer extraordinary experiences. By venturing beyond popular choices, you can enjoy unique storytelling, rich character development, and unforgettable narratives.
Hidden gems remind us that great television doesn’t always make the headlines but can profoundly impact those willing to seek it out. Don’t miss out on exploring these underrated Netflix shows and find your next favourite series.
